Discover the Thought-Provoking Poem "A Work of Artifice" by Marge Piercy
About Poet
​
Marge Piercy, who was born in 1936, is an American poet, writer, and social activist who is held in very high regard. Piercy has made major contributions to the field of modern literature through her writings, which are known for their ability to provoke thinking and for tackling topics such as feminism, social justice, and personal emancipation.
Throughout the course of her career, Piercy has been honoured with a number of prestigious awards for her work. Some of these honours include the Arthur C. Clarke Award for the Best Science Fiction Novel, the Golden Quill Award for Poetry, and the May Sarton Award for lifetime accomplishment. Her works often investigate topics relating to gender, politics, and the human experience, providing profound insights into the workings of society as well as individual conflicts.
The capacity to shed light on the intricacies of human relationships and the quest for personal identity are two themes that are prevalent throughout Piercy's poetry. These themes are characterised by the poem's powerful imagery and strong narrative voice. Her works, which often combine aspects of historical fiction with social criticism, have garnered a large following due to the fascinating writing and intriguing characters that appear in them.
In addition to her contributions to the world of literature, Piercy is an outspoken supporter of several social and environmental concerns. Her involvement displays her dedication to furthering causes related to feminism, equality, and eco-friendly ways of life. The fact that Piercy's work continues to motivate readers and spark debates on significant topics has elevated her to a prominent position in the canon of modern American literature.
Marge Piercy has made an everlasting impression on the world of literature because of her prolific writing and powerful voice in the literary community. Her writings encourage readers to wrestle with difficult concepts, cast doubt on established social mores, and acknowledge the significance of human agency. Piercy is still considered a significant and motivational personality in the fields of literature and activism, despite having a career that spans many decades.
A Work of Artifice
Marge Piercy (1936- )
The bonsai tree
in the attractive pot
could have grown eighty feet tall
on the side of a mountain
till split by lightning.
But a gardener
carefully pruned it.
It is nine inches high.
Every day as he
whittles back the branches
the gardener croons,
It is your nature
to be small and cozy,
domestic and weak;
how lucky, little tree,
to have a pot to grow in.
With living creatures
one must begin very early
to dwarf their growth:
the bound feet,
the crippled brain,
the hair in curlers,
the hands you
love to touch.
LINE BY LINE MEANING
"A Work of Artifice" by Marge Piercy:
The bonsai tree
in the attractive pot
could have grown eighty feet tall
on the side of a mountain
till split by lightning.
This opening stanza introduces us to a bonsai tree, a small tree that has been carefully cultivated and grown in a decorative pot. The poet highlights the potential of the bonsai tree to grow to a significant height if left to its natural environment. The image of the tree being split by lightning suggests a powerful force that could have contributed to its growth and transformation.
​
But a gardener
carefully pruned it.
It is nine inches high.
Every day as he
whittles back the branches
the gardener croons,
Here, the poem reveals the intervention of a gardener who prunes the bonsai tree. The pruning restricts the tree's growth, resulting in it only reaching a height of nine inches. The repetitive action of the gardener whittling back the branches suggests a deliberate and meticulous process. The use of the word "croons" implies a soothing or lulling tone, suggesting that the gardener sees this restriction as a positive and nurturing act.
It is your nature
to be small and cozy,
domestic and weak;
how lucky, little tree,
to have a pot to grow in.
In these lines, the gardener addresses the bonsai tree, attributing its inherent nature to be small, comfortable, and lacking in strength. The gardener seems to view these qualities as desirable and fortunate, suggesting that being small and contained in a pot is a suitable condition for the tree's growth.
With living creatures
one must begin very early
to dwarf their growth:
the bound feet,
the crippled brain,
the hair in curlers,
the hands you
love to touch.
In the final stanza, the poem expands its focus beyond the bonsai tree and explores a broader theme. The poet suggests that human beings, like the bonsai tree, are subjected to manipulation and restrictions. The reference to "living creatures" implies the universal experience of individuals who are molded and shaped from an early age. The examples given—bound feet, a symbol of foot-binding in certain cultures; a crippled brain, symbolizing limited intellectual growth; hair in curlers, symbolizing conformity to societal beauty standards; and hands that are loved to touch, indicating the need for control—represent different forms of imposed limitations and expectations.
Overall, "A Work of Artifice" explores themes of control, restriction, and the societal pressures that shape individuals. The poem raises questions about the nature of freedom, autonomy, and the trade-offs between nurturing and suppressing natural growth.
ANALYSIS
Â
"A Work of Artifice" by Marge Piercy is a thought-provoking poem that delves into the themes of control, restriction, and societal expectations. Through the metaphor of a bonsai tree, the poet examines the consequences of manipulating and shaping living creatures to fit predetermined molds.
Â
The poem begins by presenting the bonsai tree, a small tree grown in an attractive pot, as a symbol of potential. It highlights the tree's natural inclination to grow tall and majestic, as evidenced by the mention of it being able to reach a height of eighty feet on a mountainside. However, this potential is thwarted by the intervention of the gardener, who carefully prunes the tree, limiting its growth to a mere nine inches. This act of pruning serves as a metaphor for the ways in which individuals can be constrained and confined by external forces.
Â
The gardener's actions are depicted as deliberate and meticulous, reinforced by the repetitive and rhythmic whittling back of the branches. The gentle and soothing tone in which the gardener "croons" suggests a sense of nurturing, as if the restriction imposed on the tree is seen as a positive and protective act. This juxtaposition between restriction and care raises questions about the motives behind such control and the trade-offs between growth and containment.
Â
The gardener's words to the bonsai tree reveal a belief that its nature is to be small, cozy, and weak. This perception of the tree's inherent qualities as desirable and fortunate reflects societal expectations that value domestication and fragility. The emphasis on the tree's luck in having a pot to grow in implies that confinement and restriction are preferable to untamed growth, reinforcing the idea that conforming to societal norms is preferable to embracing one's full potential.
Â
The poem's final stanza expands its focus beyond the bonsai tree to encompass all living creatures, particularly human beings. It suggests that from an early age, individuals are subjected to manipulation and restrictions aimed at dwarfing their growth. The examples of bound feet, a crippled brain, hair in curlers, and hands that are loved to touch illustrate different forms of societal pressures and expectations imposed on individuals. These examples symbolize the physical, intellectual, and emotional constraints that individuals endure in order to conform to predetermined standards.
Â
In its entirety, "A Work of Artifice" invites reflection on the limitations and expectations placed on individuals by society. It raises questions about the nature of freedom and the consequences of shaping individuals to fit narrow molds. The poem serves as a critique of the ways in which societal norms and pressures can suppress natural growth, limit autonomy, and restrict individual potential. It encourages readers to consider the balance between nurturing and stifling, and to challenge the societal constructs that confine and define us.
QUESTION AND ANSWERS
Â
1. Â Â Â Q: What is the central metaphor in "A Work of Artifice"?
A: The central metaphor is the bonsai tree.
2. Â Â Â Q: What does the bonsai tree represent in the poem?
A: The bonsai tree represents individuals who are subjected to manipulation and restriction.
3. Â Â Â Q: How does the gardener's pruning affect the bonsai tree's growth?
A: The pruning restricts the tree's growth, limiting it to a height of nine inches.
4. Â Â Â Q: What does the repetitive whittling back of branches by the gardener suggest?
A: The repetitive action suggests a deliberate and meticulous process of control.
5. Â Â Â Q: How does the gardener's tone while whittling back the branches affect the poem's mood?
A: The gardener's soothing and lulling tone creates a sense of nurturing despite the restrictive actions.
6. Â Â Â Q: How does the poet view the bonsai tree's confinement in a pot?
A: The poet presents the confinement as lucky and desirable, emphasizing domestication and weakness.
7. Â Â Â Q: What broader theme does the final stanza of the poem explore?
A: The final stanza explores the societal pressures and limitations imposed on individuals.
8. Â Â Â Q: What do the examples of bound feet and a crippled brain symbolize?
A: They symbolize physical and intellectual restrictions imposed on individuals.
9. Â Â Â Q: What does the mention of hair in curlers represent in the poem?
A: Hair in curlers represents conformity to societal beauty standards.
10. Â Â Q: How does the poem critique societal expectations?
A: It critiques societal expectations by questioning the trade-offs between growth and conformity.
11. Â Â Q: What emotions does the poem evoke in the reader?
A: The poem evokes a sense of reflection, questioning, and the desire for personal freedom.
12. Â Â Q: How does the poem challenge traditional notions of growth and success?
A: It challenges these notions by highlighting the limitations and consequences of societal molds.
13. Â Â Q: What is the significance of the bonsai tree potentially growing on the side of a mountain?
A: It emphasizes the natural potential and grandeur that is curtailed by external intervention.
14. Â Â Q: How does the poem's use of nature imagery contribute to its message?
A: The nature imagery underscores the contrast between natural growth and imposed restrictions.
15. Â Â Q: What does the poem suggest about the importance of individual autonomy?
A: The poem suggests that individual autonomy and the pursuit of personal potential should be valued and nurtured.
MORE QUESTIONS
How does the bonsai tree in the poem differ from what it could have become in its natural environment?
What role does the gardener play in shaping the bonsai tree's growth?
Why does the gardener prune the bonsai tree every day?
What message does the gardener convey to the bonsai tree as he prunes it?
What does the poet suggest about the bonsai tree's "nature" in the context of being small and cozy?
How does the poem explore the idea of confinement and limitation?
What broader societal parallels does the poem draw through its depiction of the bonsai tree?
How do the references to "bound feet" and "crippled brain" contribute to the poem's theme?
What emotions or attitudes does the gardener's crooning convey?
How does the poem portray the relationship between humans and nature?
What is the significance of the bonsai tree having a pot to grow in, according to the poem?
In what ways does the poem critique societal norms and expectations?
How does the imagery of "hands you love to touch" add to the poem's message?
What does the poem suggest about the impact of human intervention on natural development?
How might the poem encourage readers to reconsider their attitudes toward control and manipulation in various aspects of life?
ANSWERS TO THE QUESTIONS
​
1. How does the bonsai tree in the poem differ from what it could have become in its natural environment?
The bonsai tree in the poem is confined to a small pot and meticulously pruned by a gardener, limiting its growth to a mere nine inches. In its natural environment, it could have grown to be eighty feet tall on the side of a mountain, free from human intervention.
2. What role does the gardener play in shaping the bonsai tree's growth?
The gardener plays the role of a manipulator, actively shaping and controlling the bonsai tree's growth through careful pruning and cultivation.
3. Why does the gardener prune the bonsai tree every day?
The gardener prunes the bonsai tree every day to maintain its small and cozy size, conforming it to the desired shape and appearance.
4. What message does the gardener convey to the bonsai tree as he prunes it?
The gardener conveys a message of acceptance and contentment with confinement, telling the bonsai tree that it is fortunate to be small and cozy, domestic and weak.
5. What does the poet suggest about the bonsai tree's "nature" in the context of being small and cozy?
The poet suggests that the bonsai tree's "nature" is manipulated and distorted to fit human preferences, emphasizing domesticity and weakness rather than natural growth and strength.
6. How does the poem explore the idea of confinement and limitation?
The poem explores the idea of confinement and limitation through the imagery of the bonsai tree being confined to a small pot and restricted from reaching its full potential.
7. What broader societal parallels does the poem draw through its depiction of the bonsai tree?
The poem draws parallels between the bonsai tree and individuals in society who are constrained by societal norms and expectations, facing limitations and restrictions on their growth and development.
8. How do the references to "bound feet" and "crippled brain" contribute to the poem's theme?
The references to "bound feet" and "crippled brain" serve as metaphors for the ways in which individuals are physically and mentally constrained by societal expectations, reinforcing the theme of confinement and limitation.
9. What emotions or attitudes does the gardener's crooning convey?
The gardener's crooning conveys a sense of reassurance and justification for the bonsai tree's confinement, framing it as a fortunate circumstance rather than a restriction.
10. How does the poem portray the relationship between humans and nature?
The poem portrays the relationship between humans and nature as one of manipulation and control, highlighting the tendency to impose our will on the natural world for our own purposes.
11. What is the significance of the bonsai tree having a pot to grow in, according to the poem?
The significance of the bonsai tree having a pot to grow in symbolizes the artificial environment created by humans to confine and shape nature according to our desires.
12. In what ways does the poem critique societal norms and expectations?
The poem critiques societal norms and expectations by highlighting the ways in which they restrict and distort natural growth and development, imposing limitations on individuals and shaping them to fit narrow ideals.
13. How does the imagery of "hands you love to touch" add to the poem's message?
The imagery of "hands you love to touch" evokes a sense of intimacy and familiarity but also suggests the potential for harm or manipulation, reinforcing the theme of control and confinement.
14. What does the poem suggest about the impact of human intervention on natural development?
The poem suggests that human intervention often stunts natural development, limiting potential and distorting the true essence of living beings for our own purposes.
15. How might the poem encourage readers to reconsider their attitudes toward control and manipulation in various aspects of life?
The poem encourages readers to reflect on the consequences of control and manipulation, urging them to reconsider their attitudes toward imposing limitations on others and the natural world, and to strive for greater acceptance and appreciation of diversity and freedom.